Who’s Real and Who’s Just Pretending? – Kentucky Derby Betting Preview

The 2025 Kentucky Derby is nearly here, and it's time to gear up for what promises to be an exciting "Run for the Roses." With a whole field of 20 horses expected to load into the starting gate, there's a lot of chatter about who's truly ready to take the crown and who's just another face in the crowd.

Whether you're a seasoned bettor looking to hit it big or a casual one placing your first bet on Kentucky Derby Day, knowing which horses are genuine contenders and which are pretenders is key to making smart Kentucky Derby betting decisions. Let's dive in.

Why the Derby Is a Betting Beast

The Kentucky Derby betting scene is unlike any other race in the world. With 20 horses, millions of dollars at stake, and unpredictable pace dynamics, anything can happen in Kentucky Derby odds. That's why it requires a solid understanding of each horse's strengths, weaknesses, and past performances.

The key is to focus on horses peaking at the right time, having the stamina to go the full 1¼ miles, and most importantly, being ready for the chaos, that is the Derby.

The Real Contenders

Here's a breakdown of the top contenders for the 2025 Kentucky Derby, all of whom have shown impressive form in their prep races and are in peak condition to challenge for the win:

Post Position Horse Trainer Jockey Morning Line Odds

  1. Citizen Bull Bob Baffert Martin Garcia 20-1
  2. Neoequos Saffie Joseph Jr. Flavien Prat 30-1
  3. Final Gambit Brad H. Cox Luan Machado 30-1
  4. Rodriguez Bob Baffert Mike E. Smith 12-1
  5. American Promise D. Wayne Lukas Nik Juarez 30-1
  6. Admire Daytona Yukihiro Kato Christophe Lemaire 30-1
  7. Luxor Cafe Noriyuki Hori João Moreira 30-1
  8. Journalism Michael W. McCarthy Umberto Rispoli 3-1
  9. Burnham Square Ian R. Wilkes Brian Hernandez Jr. 12-1
  10. Grande Todd A. Pletcher John R. Velazquez 20-1
  11. Flying Mohawk Whit Beckman Joseph Ramos 30-1
  12. East Avenue Brendan P. Walsh Manuel Franco 20-1
  13. Publisher Steven M. Asmussen Irad Ortiz Jr. 20-1
  14. Tiztastic Steven M. Asmussen Joel Rosario 20-1
  15. Render Judgment Kenneth G. McPeek Julien Leparoux 30-1
  16. Coal Battle Lonnie Briley Juan Vargas 30-1
  17. Sandman Mark E. Casse José Ortiz 6-1
  18. Sovereignty William I. Mott Junior Alvarado 5-1
  19. Chunk Of Gold Ethan West Jareth Loveberry 30-1
  20. Owen Almighty Brian A. Lynch Javier Castellano 30-1

Citizen Bull – A Baffert Juggernaut

🏇 Stay ahead with US Racing. Award-winning horse racing news, 2025 Kentucky Derby Prep Races odds & more. 🏆 All you need for every race 🌟

No stranger to Derby success, trainer Bob Baffert brings Citizen Bull into the 2025 Derby with high hopes. With a stunning performance in the Santa Anita Derby, this colt has shown he's ready to take on the best of the best. His pedigree is built for distance, and he could be the horse to beat with jockey Martin Garcia in the saddle. At 20-1 odds, this is a solid win bet, especially for those looking to make some noise in the exotics.

Betting Tip: Consider him as part of your exacta or trifecta.

Journalism – A Serious Threat

🏇 Stay ahead with US Racing. Award-winning horse racing news, San Felipe Stakes odds & more. 🏆 All you need for every race 🌟
Journalism at San Felipe Stakes 2025

Journalism comes into the Derby as one of the favorites with 3-1 morning-line odds. His impressive win in the Blue Grass Stakes showed he can handle a fast pace and still kick it into another gear late. He has the tactical speed and stamina to stay competitive for the entire race, making him a solid pick for win bets and trifectas.

Betting Tip: A must-use in your vertical bets, especially if you like the pace to be quick.

Rodriguez – Baffert's Other Star

Stay ahead with US Racing. Award-winning Kentucky Derby Betting news, race previews, results, odds & more. All you need for every race.
Rodriguez. Renee Torbit/Coady Photo.

Another horse from Baffert's barn, Rodriguez is no slouch, having recently won the prestigious Wood Memorial. With strong workout reports and a solid foundation, this colt is positioned well to make a late run for the roses. At 12-1 odds, Rodriguez could be an under-the-radar value pick for those looking to add some variety to their ticket.

Betting Tip: Use him in trifectas and supers.

The Pretenders: Horses to Fade

While the 2025 Kentucky Derby features a competitive field, some horses may face challenges that could hinder their performance. Here are a few horses that might not be able to handle the intensity of the Derby and could be considered "pretenders" in this year's field:

1. Chunk of Gold – Inexperienced at the Top Level

Trainer Ethan West's colt has shown promise with a second-place finish in the Louisiana Derby. However, his overall experience at the graded stakes level is limited, and he may struggle against the elite competition in the Derby. While he has potential, the lack of exposure to top-tier fields might haunt him on Derby Day.

2. Owen Almighty – Unproven Beyond Shorter Distances

While Owen Almighty secured a Grade 3 victory in the Tampa Bay Derby, his experience beyond 8.5 furlongs is minimal. The Derby is a demanding 1¼ miles, and this lack of distance experience could be a disadvantage in a field of this caliber. His lack of proven stamina at longer distances raises serious concerns about his ability to compete against the best.

3. American Promise – Stepping Up in Class

Trained by D. Wayne Lukas, American Promise won the Virginia Derby but is stepping up in class for the Kentucky Derby. His ability to handle the elite competition at this level remains uncertain, and he faces much more formidable opponents in this race than he has faced previously. He may be one to watch, but it's hard to see him beating the stronger, more experienced horses in the field.

Kentucky Derby Betting Insights for the Main Event

The 2025 Kentucky Derby is shaping to be an unforgettable race, with an exciting mix of veteran contenders and new faces ready to take their shot at immortality. For bettors, it's all about finding the right balance between value and probability. With 20 horses expected to line up, Derby Day can feel overwhelming. Still, with the right strategy, you can set yourself up for a thrilling (and hopefully profitable) day.

To make smart Kentucky Derby betting decisions, focus on horses that have proven themselves in prep races and have the stamina to go the distance. The Derby is often won by a horse primed for the challenge and has consistently improved in key prep races. Keep an eye on any late-race movement, jockey strategies, and weather conditions, as they can significantly impact the outcome.

The key to Kentucky Derby betting is being calculated, but not afraid to take risks. Sometimes, the biggest payout comes from betting on the underdog ready to step up when it counts.

Betting Tips for Derby Day:

1. Watch the Weather

The weather can play a massive role in the Derby. A wet track could level the playing field, so pay attention to the forecast and adjust your bets accordingly. Some horses handle muddy tracks better than others.

2. Spread Your Bets

Anything can happen with 20 horses in the field. Don't be afraid to spread your bets across multiple horses. Place a few win bets on the favorites and sprinkle in some longer-odds horses for exotic wagers like exactas and trifectas.

3. Focus on Value

While big names like Journalism and Citizen Bull will draw plenty of attention, don't forget to look for value. Some of the horses at 12-1, like Rodriguez or 15-1 Luxor Cafe, could offer excellent opportunities for big payouts. Be sure to examine each horse's prep race performances to see if there's hidden value.

4. Bet With Your Gut

Sometimes, horse racing is about more than just numbers. Trust your instincts if you strongly feel about a horse or a trainer. It's not always about who the experts think will win. It's about finding that one horse that could surprise everyone.

5. Focus on Exactas, Trifectas, and Superfectas

The Derby is an excellent race for exotic bets. Consider playing exactas, trifectas, and even superfectas. While they can be tough to hit, the potential rewards are massive, and with so many horses in the field, there's a good chance you can find the right combination.

6. Don't Forget About the Jockeys

A great jockey can make a huge difference in a race as chaotic as the Kentucky Derby. Experienced jockeys like Mike Smith, Irad Ortiz Jr., and John Velazquez have a history of performing well on the big stage. So, keep their mount in mind when placing your bet on jockeys.

As the mint juleps are poured and the horses prepare to load into the gate, make sure your Kentucky Derby betting strategy is locked in. With these contenders and pretenders in mind, you're ready to take on the most exciting race in America.

Proudly featured on:
up